Bristol Big'Uns » Black Sails

MikeW · 18/9/2019 7:16 PM

Warlord Games latest offering looks interesting until you realise that the ships are in a scale not used by any other manufacturer and a single 1st rate ship, like HMS Victory, will cost £24 for a resin hull kit which has to be assembled. Given that this is about twice the price of Langton ships I struggle to see how this will be popular.

Also given Warlord Games recent track record for releasing rules that have not been properly tested or proof read I for one will be sticking with Warhammer Historical Trafalgar rules and many others will no doubt stick with Sails of Glory where the ships are cheaper and come ready painted and assembled. Or - speaking as a fan of Peter Dennis’ paper soldiers - I might suggest the Battle of Trafalgar book which has every ship of both fleets in profile.

Mike

Old g*t · 19/9/2019 11:13 AM

I'm ahead of you with this one, Mike.
I'm convinced it's another poor money making Warlord offering.

Cheers

robb · 22/9/2019 9:31 AM

Ouch!!

Agree with both of you

I have a load of tiremes from Langton somewhere - was going to write some rules but are there any decent ones out there?

robb · 22/9/2019 9:37 AM

Found Poseidon’s Warriors from Osprey
but rules reviews are very mixed. I recall the author proposed this to me when I was at Games Workshop!

Perhaps I should write my own!

Last edited by robb (22/9/2019 9:38 AM)

Lurkus Spleen · 22/9/2019 9:42 AM

Also agree chaps, seems Warlord are going down the same root as GW, bang ok boxed games after box game, make as much money as possible then move on to the next. The problem with Warlord is GW’s Quality is so much better.

MikeW · 22/9/2019 3:05 PM

Rob

I have Poseidon’s Warriors but haven’t yet played it and like you read varying reports. I previously used Naumachiae which gave a decent game but could be a bit slow.

Mike

robb · 24/9/2019 8:17 PM

Mike

as arranged look forward to Sundays battle - ships ahoy !!

Ujkakevin · 25/9/2019 10:01 AM

robb wrote:
Ouch!!

Agree with both of you

I have a load of tiremes from Langton somewhere - was going to write some rules but are there any decent ones out there?

Rob,

Don’t know how good the rules are but Firelock Games have a 1/600th game called Oak and Thunder due out soon (I became aware of it on Kickstarter). Have heard good things about their 28mm Blood and Plunder rules so might be worth a look if/when they come out.

Kevin

Old g*t · 25/9/2019 1:08 PM

I think it's now called oak & iron.

Marketing vids - https://www.firelockgames.com/oak-iron/

Enjoy

robb · 26/9/2019 8:08 PM

Thanks..

the ships look interesting but I must avoid any more new stuff, I have existing new stuff to paint and game with!

Ujkakevin · 01/10/2019 2:32 AM

A pdf of the Oak and Iron rules has just been made available at https://www.firelockgames.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Oak-Iron-Rulebook-full.pdf - unfortunately the cards for ships etc aren’t available so hard to play test

Index
» Club Discussion
» Black Sails

18/9/2019 7:16 PM #1

Black Sails

19/9/2019 11:13 AM #2

Re: Black Sails

22/9/2019 9:31 AM #3

Re: Black Sails

22/9/2019 9:37 AM #4

Re: Black Sails

22/9/2019 9:42 AM #5

Re: Black Sails

22/9/2019 3:05 PM #6

Re: Black Sails

24/9/2019 8:17 PM #7

Re: Black Sails

25/9/2019 10:01 AM #8

Re: Black Sails

robb wrote:

25/9/2019 1:08 PM #9

Re: Black Sails

26/9/2019 8:08 PM #10

Re: Black Sails

01/10/2019 2:32 AM #11

Re: Black Sails

Index
» Club Discussion
» Black Sails

Board footera